Tuesday March 21, 2023
| Last update: Tuesday at 9:00 AM

House Republicans pass Trumpcare Version 2

By Masao Suzuki |
May 5, 2017
Read more articles in

San José, CA - On Wednesday, May 3, House Republicans passed Trumpcare Version 2 with only two votes to spare. President Trump lobbied heavily to get the amended American Health Care Act (AHCA) through the House of Representatives. To win over the ultra-right wing so-called Freedom Caucus, House leader Paul Ryan added amendments that would allow states to opt out of the minimum requirements for health insurance introduced by Obamacare.

The Affordable Care Act or ACA, popularly known as Obamacare, mandates a number of benefits that health insurance has to cover. Under Trumpcare Version 2, states could opt out, allowing for-profit health insurance companies to offer insurance without emergency room or hospital coverage, maternity care, mental health and drug abuse, prescription drugs, and lab tests. This opens the door for millions of people to be underinsured - having health insurance but leaving gaps that can drive people into bankruptcy or not getting the health care that they need.

In particular, Trumpcare Version 2 allows states to let insurance companies charge higher prices for people with pre-existing conditions. Almost 60 million adults have pre-existing health conditions, and 2 million of them could lose their health insurance. This would be in addition to the 24 million who will lose coverage from Trumpcare mainly from cuts in Medicaid and loss of employer health benefits (under the ACA, larger companies are required to offer health insurance to their workers, this is not the case under Trumpcare).

While Trump and House Republicans bragged about the extra $8 billion dollars added to help pay for insurance for people with pre-existing conditions who would be put into ‘high-risk pools.’ This money, along with the $15 billion already in the bill, is only enough to cover a bit more than 100,000 people, a tiny fraction of the more than 2 million people who buy their own health insurance that have pre-existing conditions. If Texas or Florida, two states that have already opted out of the Medicaid expansion under the ACA, were to allow higher charges for preexisting conditions, the total money available nationwide would only cover half the people who need help in just one state.

Why are President Trump and the House Republicans so intent on taking health insurance from 26 million Americans? Many mainstream groups such as the AARP, the American Medical Association, and the American Hospital Association all opposed Trumpcare. But Trumpcare is being pushed by the president and House Republicans because it would end the taxes on high-income individuals that help to pay for Obamacare, saving the rich billions of dollars. In addition, the cut in health spending would pave the way for Trump and the House Republicans’ tax plan, which would cut taxes on the rich by billions more.

The bill now moves to the Senate where it is expected to encounter stiff resistance.